Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Facebook stories


You spend half the day browsing through pictures of friends on Facebook. Change your status six times a day. And have a number of friends somewhere in the four digits. Congratulations, you're a Facebook addict.

Facebook, The Social Network, has changed and touched the life of millions. Facebook is all about the individual and collective experiences of you and your friends. It's filled with hundreds of millions of stories.

Which ones inspire you? What's your Facebook story? Is it a story about love, family, friendship, religion, health, education, university, travel, or other? Is it a story about happiness or grief?
Millions of stories by location and theme have been shared on stories.facebook.com.


Facebook has more than 500 million members, and more than half of them use Facebook every day, with growth accelerating thanks to mobile.

Week 8: Ethics and Law in New Media

November 8-14

Topic 15: The Proprietary World: The WIPO Intellectual Property model
Topic 16: More WIPO: Contracts and Licenses

Study the Anglo-American and Continental European school of IP. Write a short comparative analysis to your blog (if you have clear preference for one over another, explain that, too).

The recognition and protection of private property rights, including IP, largely depends on whether a nation is a common law or civil law jurisdiction, and also, on whether it has adopted a Continental or an Anglo-American form of capitalism as its national economic system.


Blue: Civil law. Red: Common law. Brown: Bijuridical (civil and common law).
Green: Customary law. Yellow: Fiqh.

It is often said that the common law is primarily concerned with the protection of economic rights, whereas countries that follow civil law tradition concentrate on the moral rights of the author and analogous creators. While there is doubtless a great deal of oversimplification in these views, and maybe even a measure of racial stereotyping, there is also more than a grain of truth. (David T. Keeling, Intellectual Property Rights in EU Law: Free Movement and Competition Law, pp. 263)

The prime inspiration for both systems, the Continental and the Anglo-American, is the cultural importance of authors, but the focus of the Continental European is even more the author while the Anglo-American is more focused on the commercial part of the copyright. Copyright protection is divided into two categories, economic rights and moral rights. Moral rights focus more on the author as a person while economic rights focus on the financial profit which can be made from a work.

Moral rights include the right of attribution, the right to have a work published anonymously or pseudonymously, and the right to the integrity of the work. The preserving of the integrity of the work bars the work from alteration, distortion, or mutilation. Moral rights are distinct from any economic rights tied to copyrights. Even if an artist has assigned his or her rights to a work to a third party, he or she still maintains the moral rights to the work. In most of Europe, it is not possible for authors to assign their moral rights (unlike the copyright itself, which is regarded as an item of property which can be sold, licensed, lent, mortgaged or given like any other property). They can agree not to enforce them and such terms are very common in contracts in Europe. Moral rights have had a less robust tradition within the Anglo-American school, where the protection for moral rights has, up until today, been very slim and is still not as strong as within the Continental European school.

The most important international convention which regulates copyright is the Berne Convention. The convention was a compromise between the Anglo-American approach and the Continental European approach. Article 6bis of the Berne Convention protects attribution and integrity, stating: Independent of the author's economic rights, and even after the transfer of the said rights, the author shall have the right to claim authorship of the work and to object to any distortion, mutilation or other modification of, or other derogatory action in relation to the said work, which would be prejudicial to the author's honor or reputation. However, when the United States signed the Berne Convention, it stipulated that the Convention's "moral rights" provisions were addressed sufficiently by other statutes, such as laws covering slander and libel.

Despite the laws being standardized to some extent, consistencies among different nations remain, each jurisdiction has separate and distinct laws and regulations about copyright. The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) summarizes each of its member states' intellectual property laws on its website. WIPO is a specialized agency of the United Nations that was established by the WIPO Convention in 1967 with a mandate from its Member States to promote the protection of IP throughout the world through cooperation among states and in collaboration with other international organizations. Its headquarters are in Geneva, Switzerland.

See World Intellectual Property Organization - An Overview (2010 Edition) for more information.

WIPO launches WIPO Lex, a one-stop search facility for national laws and treaties on intellectual property of WIPO, WTO and UN Members.

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Task 7: In search for my own understanding of interactivity

The two articles on interactivity previously studied, „Interactivity: Tracking a New Concept in Media and Communication Studies“ by J. F. Jensen and „Interactivity: A Concept Explication“ by S. K. Kiousis, both confirmed that the concept of interactivity is certainly multi-discursive and thus depends to a very large extent on the context in which it is used for the meaning to be clear. This makes the search for our own understanding of interactivity a great quest to take on where no interpretation can be wrong.

According to J. D. Peters, author of the prophetic book called “Speaking into the Air: A History of the Idea of Communication”, the ideal of interactivity, the search for instantaneous contact with others, has a long and fraught history in western culture. He traced it back to St Augustine, for whom the epitome of perfect communication was the angel, a word derived from the Greek for “messenger”. Coming back to the 21st century, Jensen writes, “The culture has lived out what we might call an interactive turn“. Because interactivity as we know it today is so closely tied to technology, many of the explications – including the one elaborated by Kiousis – make mediated communication via technology a central attribute defining interactivity and exclude pure interpersonal communication.
Or as Peters argues, the aim of modern media has been to “mimic the angels by mechanical or electronic means”.

To illustrate the situation, I would like to share a video recently reviewed by one of my fellow students on his blog. The video that brought goosebumps to me, reminds us that interpersonal communication, even though often substituted – or, as it would be more correct to say, mediated – by the various means of interactive computer technology, continues to play an important role in our life.

From the academic perspective, we may analyze the term interactivity referring, first and foremost, to the fields of sociology, communication studies and informatics (including information and computer science), but when we think of interactivity, in search for our own understanding of one of the media community’s most used buzzwords, we often perceive it best in the context of personal experience. As the second half of the definiton by Kiousis explicates, „With regard to human users, it [interactivity] additionally refers to their ability to perceive the experience as a simulation of interpersonal communication and increase their awareness of telepresence.“ Moreover, most interactive computing systems are for some human purpose and interact with humans in human contexts.

Interactivity is a central concept in new media. In simple words, interactive new media holds out a possibility of on-demand access to content any time, anywhere, on any digital device, as well as interactive user feedback, creative participation and community formation around the media content. It also breaks the connection between physical place and social place, making physical location much less significant for our social relationships, and has the ability to connect like-minded others worldwide. Social interaction, using web-based technologies to turn communication into interactive dialogues, has become part of our personal and professional life. Popular networking sites such as Facebook and Twitter as well as personal weblogs are commonly used for socialization and connecting with friends, relatives, and employees, wherever in the world they may currently be.

Interactivity, the way I feel and perceive it, even though closely tied to technology, is a measure of a media’s potential ability to help the user connect, interplay, socialize, retrieve, personalize and exchange information, give feedback, form and participate in communities, or in other words, a means that helps to keep the interpersonal communication alive at any time, anywhere, with anyone we choose to. This communication is hoped to be a mutual (reciprocal) lively action, just like the words ’inter’ and ’activity’ presume and just like we expect communication to always be. True, we can also communicate and interact with a computer software, Internet website, or whatever other artifact, but I find the social connotations more cherished.

To answer the question whether interactivity as a concept has changed in the past 10, 100 or 1000 years, I believe the heart of it has remained the same. What changes constantly is the technology we employ to interact and the degree to which this technology makes the interaction possible. Patently, the level of interactivity varies within different media and is ever higher as more advanced technologies are introduced. Theoretical and operational definitons are useful to understand the background behind the concept, however, interactivity must be "touched and felt" (perceived) as part of our life to mean more than a concept explication to us.

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Week 7: Ethics and Law in New Media

November 1-7

Topic 13: The Author vs the Information Society

Read Chapter 3 "Against Intellectual Property" of the Brian Martin's book. Write a blog review (especially, comment on his strategies for change).


What is intellectual property?

Intellectual property (IP) is a term referring to a number of distinct types of creations of the mind for which property rights are recognized – and the corresponding fields of law. Under intellectual property law, owners are granted certain exclusive rights to a variety of intangible assets, such as musical, literary, and artistic works; discoveries and inventions; and words, phrases, symbols, and designs. Common types of intellectual property include copyrights, trademarks, patents, industrial design rights and trade secrets in some jurisdictions.
Critisism of intellectual property

Some critics of intellectual property, such as those in the free culture movement, point at intellectual monopolies as harming health, preventing progress, and benefiting concentrated interests to the detriment of the masses, and argue that the public interest is harmed by ever expansive monopolies in the form of copyright extensions, software patents and business method patents.

There is also criticism because strict intellectual property rights can inhibit the flow of innovations to poor nations. Developing countries have benefited from the spread of developed country technologies, such as the internet, mobile phone, vaccines, and high-yielding grains. Many intellectual property rights, such as patent laws, arguably go too far in protecting those who produce innovations at the expense of those who use them.

The classic argument for copyright is the view that granting developers temporary monopolies over their works encourages further development and creativity by giving the developer a source of income. A central anti-copyright argument is that copyright has never been of net benefit to society and instead serves to enrich a few at the expense of creativity.

Or as Brian Martin puts it: "Intellectual work is inevitably a collective process. No one has totally original ideas: ideas are always built on the earlier contributions of others. Intellectual property is theft, sometimes in part from an individual creator but always from society as a whole."

The alternative to intellectual property is straightforward: intellectual products should not be owned, as in the case of everyday language. That means not owned by individuals, corporations, governments, or the community as common property. It means that ideas are available to be used by anyone who wants to. Strategies against intellectual property include civil disobedience, promotion of non-owned information, and fostering of a more cooperative society. Challenging intellectual property must involve the development of methods to support creative individuals.

Strategies for change

  • Change thinking. Rather than talk of intellectual property in terms of property and trade, it should be talked about in terms of free speech and its impediments. Once intellectual property is undermined in the minds of many citizens, it will become far easier to topple its institutional supports.
  • Expose the costs. It can cost a lot to set up and operate a system of intellectual property. For instance, a middle-ranking country from the First World, such as Australia, pays far more for intellectual property - mostly to the US - than it receives. Once the figures are available and understood, this will aid in reducing the legitimacy of the world intellectual property system.
  • Reproduce protected works. From the point of view of intellectual property, this is called "piracy". This happens every day when people photocopy copyrighted articles, tape copyrighted music, or duplicate copyrighted software. Unfortunately, illegal copying is not a very good strategy against intellectual property, any more than stealing goods is a way to challenge ownership of physical property.
  • Openly refuse to cooperate with intellectual property. This is far more powerful than illicit copying. The methods of nonviolent action can be used here, including noncooperation, boycotts and setting up alternative institutions. By being open about the challenge, there is a much greater chance of focussing attention on the issues at stake and creating a dialogue. Once mass civil disobedience to intellectual property laws occurs, it will be impossible to stop.
  • Promote non-owned information. A good example is public domain software, which is computer software that is made available free to anyone who wants it. A suitable alternative to copyright is shareright. A piece of freeware might be accompanied by the notice, "You may reproduce this material if your recipients may also reproduce it." Another approach, called copyleft, requires those who pass on a free program to include the rights to use, modify, and redistribute the code; the code and the freedoms become legally inseparable. The developers of "freeware" gain satisfaction out of their intellectual work and out of providing a service to others.
  • Develop principles to deal with credit for intellectual work. In a more cooperative society, credit for ideas would not be such a contentious matter. In a society with less hierarchy and greater equality, intrinsic motivation and satisfaction would be the main returns from contributing to intellectual developments. The less there is to gain from credit for ideas, the more likely people are to share ideas rather than worry about who deserves credit for them. Nonetheless, principles to deal with credit for intellectual work remain important even if credit is not rewarded financially. This includes guidelines for not misrepresenting another person's work.

Analyzing the proposed stategies for change, what seems right and what seems wrong?

Pros

As someone who has published a book, I'm personally against the strategy of reproducing protected works. Any illicit violation should not be tolerated, which doesn't mean that the authors of some creative work wouldn't be willing to share their intellectual property if kindly asked. We cannot expect people whose only income relies on books they write, photographs they take or programs they create to always share their work without any cost, or to gain satisfaction only out of providing a free service to others, which other times might freely be the case. Sometimes we do produce works purely for personal satisfaction, or even for respect and recognition from peers. Other times, we kindly share part of our creative work for free, and by doing that, still contribute to the humanly need to share or, from a cultural perspective, to mash-up culture and knowledge in search of enrichment. An example of how partial sharing might be useful is the business model of Google Books, which displays millions of pages of copyrighted and uncopyrighted books as part of a business plan drawing its revenue from advertising. At the same time, Google Books blocks-out large sections of those same books, which incentivizes purchases, and supports the legitimate interests of rights holders.

Copyright is meant to protect creators. New innovations are often both creatively and expensive endeavors. The creation of copyright laws has protected innovators from investing huge amounts of time and money into a project, only to have it stolen. The establishment of the copyright laws has also led to more creators documenting their innovations. Prior to copyright laws, individuals were extra secretive, sometimes choosing not to document the innovation for fear of the idea being stolen.

Cons

While offering advantages, such as protecting creators, copyright laws also have some disadvantages, like creating monopolies. The right to monopolize the sale of the product or its reproduction puts a lot of power in the hands of one person or company. Monopolies over items, like prescription drugs, means that companies can charge any amount they desire, making the medicine too expensive for lower socioeconomic families or individuals to afford. Unfortunately, copyright laws most often benefit large corporations and businesses, rather than individuals. Instead of helping the public with innovations, they become a costly burden that can only be accessed by the wealthy. Companies also rely on outdated patents to generate income rather than creating new, more efficient innovations. This is where the mass civil disobedience to intellectual property laws might help. By cooperatively and solidly showing the discontent, there is indeed a greate chance of focussing attention on the issues at stake and creating a dialogue with the copyright holders.

In the context of the Internet and Web 2.0 it is quite obvious that copyright law needs to be adapted to modern information technology. Copyright has become obsolete with regards to the Internet, the cost of trying to enforce it is unreasonable, and instead business models need to adapt to the reality of the darknet (a phrase used to refer collectively to all covert communication networks). Many citizens of the Internet want to share their work - and the power to reuse, modify, and distribute their work - with others on generous terms. This is particularly so in the context of Web 2.0 and the increase in user generated content. However, it is also true that many of the Web 2.0 users often do not realise that they are inadvertently engaging in copyright infringements (the most common case, quite actual for us as new media students, is blogging and the associated passing around of articles and images). Yet, we all have become to love the free and open source software and want the collaborative creation to continue, which programs us to support the strategy of promoting non-owned information.

To conclude

In one way or another, if intellectual property is to be challenged, people need to be reassured that misappropriation of ideas will not become a big problem. Creative society still needs some sort of laws, but perhaps they should be less constricting, such as the above mentioned shareright and copyleft alternatives. Creative Commons, a non-profit organization devoted to expanding the range of creative works available for others to build upon legally and to share, also states that it is not anti-copyright per se, but argues for copyright to be managed in a more flexible and open way.

Current copyright system needs to be brought into line with reality and the needs of society. Hipatia argues that this would "provide the ethical principles which allow the individual to spread his/her knowledge, to help him/herself, to help his/her community and the whole world, with the aim of making society ever more free, more equal, more sustainable, and with greater solidarity." As pointed out by Martin in the article, "in a society with less hierarchy and greater equality, intrinsic motivation and satisfaction would be the main returns from contributing to intellectual developments."

Cory Doctorow and Boing Boing


Cory Doctorow, a Canadian blogger, journalist and science fiction author as well as an activist in favour of liberalising copyright laws and a proponent of the Creative Commons organisation, believes that copyright laws should be liberalized to allow for free sharing of all digital media. He has also advocated filesharing. He argues that copyright holders should have a monopoly on selling their own digital media, and copyright laws should only come into play when someone attempts to sell a product currently under someone else's copyright. Doctorow is an opponent of digital rights management (DRM), claiming that it limits the free sharing of digital media and frequently causes problems for legitimate users (including registration problems that lock users out of their own purchases and prevent them from being able to move their media to other devices and platforms).


Boing Boing is a publishing entity, first established as a magazine, later becoming a group blog (co-edited by Cory Doctorow). Boing Boing became a website in 1995 and later relaunched as a weblog on January 21, 2000, described as a "directory of wonderful things." The site's own original content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial license, as of August 2008.

Topic 14: The History and Development of Copyright

No task here this week.

Sunday, October 31, 2010

Projektijuhtimine: Kodutöö 2

Locamotion projekti WBS (Work Breakdown Structure).

WBS on projekti kohta aktuaalsem, kuna tegelik ajagraafik saab olema tugevalt mõjutatud meeskonna ajast ning õppetööga seotud võimalustest.

Kodutöö autorid on Kristo Vaher ja Kairi Fimberg. Kogu info ja failid leiab Kristo blogist.





Task 6: Operationalising interactivity (article 2)

New Interactive Environments

Article summary

Kiousis, S. (2002). Interactivity: A Concept Explication.

As we read from the previous article by Jens F. Jensen, the meaning of interactivity has been relatively unclear ever since the word appeared in daily use with the rise of new media and communication technologies. The purpose of the project carried out by Spiro K. Kiousis, a professor at the University of Florida, is to engender a detailed explication of interactivity that could bring some consensus to how the concept should be theoretically and operationally defined.

Following Chaffee's framework for concept explication, the following steps were executed to complete the project: (1) provide a general background of interactivity; (2) survey relevant literature on the concept; (3) identify the concept's central operational properties; (4) locate present definitions of the concept; (5) evaluate and modify those definitions; (6) propose a conceptual definition; (7) propose an operational definition; and (8) discuss the implications on future research of the arrived-at definition.

Kiousis uses two dimensions to arrange the various conceptual definitions and cogent aspects of interactivity discussions from the fields of communication, sociology, psychology, and computer/science design: the object emphasized by scholars (technology, communication setting, perceiver), and the intellectual perspective from which the definition originates (comminication and non-communication). He organizes the different authors visually in a table and uses it as a reference for the remainder of his project.

According to Kiousis' modified definition, interactivity can be defined as the degree to which a communication technology can create a mediated environment in which participants can communicate (one-to-one, one-to-many, and many-to-many), both synchronously and asynchronously, and participate in reciprocal message exchanges (third-order dependency). With regard to human users, it additionally refers to their ability to perceive the experience as a simulation of interpersonal communication and increase their awareness of telepresence.

Operationally, interactivity is established by three factors: technological structure of the media used (e.g. speed, range, timing flexibility, and sensory complexity), characteristics of communication settings (e.g. third-order dependency and social presence), and individuals' perceptions (e.g. proximity, perceived speed, sensory activation, and telepresence). Operational measures are needed to examine each of these factors. Once the data is collected, it is transformed, producing technological, communication context, and perceived interactivity scores. Subsequently, an overall interactivity score can be manufactured.

On the whole, the operational definition offered not only describes the essence of the theoretical definition of interactivity, but may also help broaden the concept's boundaries. In comparison to previous versions, the interactivity definition provided by Kiousis is expansive, permitting analyses across media and individuals. Interactivity is understood as both a media and psychological factor that varies across communication technologies, communication contexts, and people's perceptions.

Inevitably, interactivity still remains a controversial concept.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Task 5: From interaction to interactivity, from sociology to informatics (article 1)

New Interactive Environments

What is interactivity?

In computer science, interactive refers to software which accepts and responds to input from humans; for example, data or commands. By comparison, noninteractive programs operate without human contact; examples of these include compilers and batch processing applications.

Interactivity is seen as a key association with new media as it basically sets apart the 'old' and new medias. Old media could only offer a sit-back type interaction, whereas new media is much more engaging to their audiences. Technologies such as DVDs and digital TV are classic examples of interactive media devices, where a user can control what they watch and when. However, the Internet has become the prime model of an interactive system. Users can become fully immersed in their experiences by viewing material, commenting on it and then actively contributing to it.

Designers have often wondered about the secret ingredient to make a website appealing. The combination of design and functionality is something every designer wishes to implement in a site. Many successful websites have one main secret ingredient, not every designer is aware about. That element is website interactivity.

Some examples of great interactivity websites
Left: Starbucks Coffee at Home. Right: Square Circle (Creative Agency)

Literature review

Jensen, J.F. (1998). Interactivity: Tracking a New Concept in Media and Communication Studies.

When Jensen wrote his review on interactivity as a new concept in media and communications studies in 1998, the term 'interactivity' (along with 'multimedia', 'hypermedia', 'media convergence', 'digitization', 'information superhighway', etc), was presumably among the words surrounded by the greatest amount of hype. At the same time, it seemed relatively unclear just what 'interactivity' and 'interactive media' meant, which made it one of the media community's most used buzzwords – to the extent where the meaning was watered down in daily usage.

However, one thing was sure. The concept appeared loaded with positive connotations along the lines of high tech, technological advancement, hypermodernity and futurism, along the lines of individual freedom of choice, personal development, self determination – and even along the lines of folksy popularization, grassroots democracy, and political independence.

Jensen made an attempt to track the concept of 'interactivity' and to suggest a new definition for the much-hyped but underdefined phenomenon, trying to overcome the blind spot at a time when most of the media handbooks remained silent on it. Referring to the matrix with four principally different communication patterns (transmission, consultation, conversation, registration), developed by Bordewijk and Kaam in 1986, Jensen came to a conclusion that the new media could hardly be described using traditional one way communication models and terminology. After a long, at some point confusing, analysis over the meaning of the concept of 'interactivity' in three main academic fields (sociology, communication studies and informatics), followed by 1- to n-dimensional models of the same concept from a number of different authors, he returned to the above mentioned matrix to build his suggestion on it.

According to Jensen, there appears to be a particular difference in interactivity which consists of a choice from a selection of available information content, interactivity which consists of producing information via input to a system, and interactivity which consists of the system's ability to adapt and respond to a user. Based on the four patterns, he suggested different – mutually independent – dimensions of interactivity and defined it as a measure of a media's potential ability to let the user exert an influence on the content and/or form of the mediated communication. Since consultational and transmissional interactivity both concern the availability of choice (respectively with and without a request) it is possible to represent them within the same dimension of selective interactivity. The four types of interactivity (transmissional, consultational, conversational and registrational) can then be presented in a 3-dimensional graphic model – an 'interactivity cube' with results in 12 different types of interactive media. Jensen admitted it was not a complete resolution, in the sense of finding the ultimate definition for 'interactivity', yet he had made a contribution toward a hopefully greater understanding of the meaning of 'interactivity'.

A dozen years later, we have, with one accord, agreed that interactive power of computer and communications technology, computer-enabled consumer devices (the possibility of on-demand access to content any time, anywhere, on any digital device, as well as interactive user feedback, creative participation and community formation) and most importantly the Internet (which is why we talk a lot about website interactivity) forms the core of new media. In fact, this is what distinguishes new media from traditional media – the dynamic life of the content and its interactive relationship with the consumer. This dynamic life moves, breathes and flows with pulsing excitement in real time, which makes new media (and therefore also interactivity) a concept hard to track. What was new yesterday, or today, won't be new tomorrow.